1984 volume 11(3) pages 263 – 277
doi:10.1068/b110263

Cite as:
Choukroun J-M, 1984, "The validation of models of complex systems" Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 11(3) 263 – 277

Download citation data in RIS format

The validation of models of complex systems

J-M Choukroun

Received 9 January 1984

Abstract. This paper begins with a short review of various approaches to validation proposed in the modeling literature. It then discusses three alternative views of models: (1) the concept of model in mathematical logic, (2) the conventional (empiricist) view of models in the social sciences, and (3) an alternative view that sees models as the products of metaphor construction and interpretation. This third view leads to the identification of four different areas in model validation: (1) evaluation of adequacy of metaphors, (2) observation, measurement, and experimentation, (3) internal validation, and (4) external validation. The process of external validation proposed here recognizes that models are inherently partial, incomplete, and somewhat idiosyncratic and need to be confronted and compared with each other to produce new insights collectively.

PDF Full-text PDF size: 2051 Kb