1982 volume 14(8) pages 1113 – 1120
doi:10.1068/a141113

Cite as:
Kim Y-S, 1982, "Simon's steady state assumption: a critique of Okabe's critique" Environment and Planning A 14(8) 1113 – 1120

Download citation data in RIS format

Simon's steady state assumption: a critique of Okabe's critique

Y-S Kim

Received 2 October 1980, in revised form 25 September 1981

Abstract. Simon's model of city-size distributions has been a classical way of explaining the rank - size rule. But the steady state condition he uses to solve his model was shown by Okabe to be mathematically inconsistent with the basic postulates of the model. Okabe is correct as long as the difference between individual city size and total population is small. But when t (total number of population units) is only moderately larger than i (individual city size), as it always would be in actual applications of this model, Simon's steady state assumption is found to be very reasonable. Thus, users of the Simon model need not concern themselves with the fine points and complexities of Okabe's exposition since Simon's steady state assumption holds for any value of t that might be empirically observed.

PDF Full-text PDF size: 522 Kb